Jump to content

  • Welcome to Auto Parts Forum

    Whether you are a veteran automotive parts guru or just someone looking for some quick auto parts advice, register today and start a new topic in our forum. Registration is free and you can even sign up with social network platforms such as Facebook, X, and LinkedIn. 

     

Don’t Back Down When Recommending Ride Control

Counterman
 Share

Recommended Posts

Counterman Contributor

Counterman

Posted
Posted

I get “flop sweats” when I panic. One of my worst cases was when working the front counter at a tire dealer. We had just inspected a Ford Taurus with a broken passenger-side spring and about 75,000 miles on the clock. The customer dropped off the car in the morning complaining of a knocking noise and notchy steering.

I was on the phone with the customer at 9:30, getting approval on the recommended work. The estimate I wrote was for four struts, two springs and front upper strut mounts. I spent extra time finding parts, looking up labor times and calculating the out-the-door price.

Then the customer asked, “Is there a less expensive option?” That’s when the flop sweats started. It got worse after he asked, “Can I get away with just replacing the fronts?”

I quickly pulled out my calculator and rewrote the estimate on the fly for just the front struts, springs and upper mounts. After giving him the price, he asked if it would be half that price if he did only one side. My manager could see the sweat on my face and tapped me on the shoulder. “Tell the customer you will call him back in 10 minutes with an accurate estimate because you need to talk to the technician.”

He told me that the only way the shop would do the job was to do it the right way. He explained that if we did just the front struts, it would make the vehicle unstable. Replacing only one strut would make the car unsafe and impossible to align. He said the customer would be unsatisfied if we did not do both front and rear struts. He might complain about a steering pull tomorrow, uneven tire wear in a month or that he could not control the vehicle.

“If the customer does not buy something from us today, we will not go out of business. But, if they buy something unsafe, it could put us out of business.”

Looking back, I was more concerned about the customer walking out of the shop without buying anything than doing the job the right way to make the vehicle functional and safe. I was looking for approval for my ego and not approval for a sound repair.

All or Nothing

Shocks, struts and springs do not operate independently. The condition of one corner of the suspension affects all the corners of the vehicle when driving straight or cornering. At low speeds, it might not be as noticeable, but it still happens. At higher speeds and cornering forces, the inability to control the movement of the suspension and body in one corner can change the contact patch for all the corners. During a panic situation, an unbalanced suspension with worn ride control can alter the contact patch to the point where the vehicle oversteers, understeers or can’t stop.

The stability-control system measures the effectiveness of its correction in real time. How effective the correction is depends on the condition of the contact patch of the tires. What influences the health of this contact patch is the tire’s condition (construction, traction and even inflation) and the condition of the chassis components like the struts.

The computer does not assign a value to the condition of the contact patch and there are no parameters (PIDs) in the programming for most systems. The corrections and the effectiveness are measured by the sensors in a high-speed feedback loop.

A stability-control system will never set a malfunction light if the condition of the contact patch crosses a set threshold. But, as the condition of the chassis and tires diminishes, the corrections become less effective and more actions will be needed to bring a vehicle under control.

These stability-control sensors are essentially blind to the condition of the state of the ride control and suspension. The software and sensors can’t diagnose a strut that has lost its gas charge or if a spring is weak. It just sees the results as data coming from the sensors. To the algorithms in the software, it could be a patch of ice or an over-loaded car. But, the reality is that it could be a worn out strut and a spring with a missing coil.

Basically, if the suspension is not up to snuff, the correction by the system will take longer. This results in longer stopping distances or, in some cases, the vehicle ending up on its roof.

For example, the most basic stability and ABS correction is a panic stop in a straight line. When the driver mashes the brake pedal, weight transfers to the front tires, loads the front suspension and causes the springs to compress. How much the springs compress is influenced directly by the condition of the shocks or struts. When the springs compress, the contact patch of the tires changes due to the weight and geometry of the suspension.

The rear suspension is even more interesting. When the weight loads the front tires, the rear spring expands, which makes the contact patch of the rear tire smaller. If the shock or strut is unable to control the rebound of the spring, additional weight is transferred to the front, which nosedives even more.

Applied to the front counter at your shop, it means that you should never sell just one strut, shock or spring. Also, you should be very careful selling just front or rear ride-control units. This approach might get the customer back on the road, but not in a safe vehicle.

So, what did the customer do with his Taurus? After calming down and wiping the sweat from my brow, I explained why we recommended replacing all four struts. He finally understood and decided to replace all four struts and both front springs.

The moral of the story: Stand by your recommendations. You’re not doing your customers any favors by recommending a less expensive part or repair.

The post

link hidden, please login to view
appeared first on
link hidden, please login to view
.

link hidden, please login to view

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Similar Topics

    • Clifford Auto Parts
      Understanding OEM Control Modules: What You Need to Know
      By Clifford Auto Parts
      When it comes to modern vehicles, the performance and reliability we expect are largely due to the integration of sophisticated electronics and systems. One such essential component is the OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) Control Module. These modules play a critical role in the functionality of a vehicle, ensuring that everything from engine performance to safety features is operating at its best. But what exactly are OEM control modules, and why are they so important?
      What Are OEM Control Modules?
      OEM control modules are electronic units that control and monitor various functions within a vehicle. These modules are designed and produced by the vehicle’s original manufacturer, which ensures that they meet the highest standards for performance, durability, and compatibility. These modules are responsible for managing crucial systems in a vehicle, such as the engine control system (ECM), transmission control, and braking systems.
      Unlike aftermarket parts, which are produced by third-party manufacturers, OEM control modules are specifically designed to match the vehicle’s make, model, and year. As a result, they offer a precise fit and functionality, ensuring the highest level of performance and reliability.
      Why Are OEM Control Modules Important?
      Enhanced Vehicle Performance: OEM control modules are engineered to interact seamlessly with the other systems in a vehicle. When these modules are working properly, they ensure that the vehicle runs at optimal efficiency, offering better fuel economy, smoother driving, and reduced emissions.
      Guaranteed Compatibility: Since OEM control modules are made by the vehicle’s original manufacturer, they are guaranteed to be fully compatible with the vehicle’s systems. This eliminates concerns about compatibility issues that might arise with aftermarket parts, making the replacement or upgrade process much simpler and less risky.
      Durability and Reliability: OEM control modules are built to last. They are designed using the same high-quality materials and manufacturing processes used for the original vehicle components, ensuring they offer long-lasting performance. When you choose an OEM module, you're investing in quality that won't let you down.
      Warranty and Support: Many OEM control modules come with a warranty, providing peace of mind that any defects or issues will be covered. Additionally, support from the vehicle’s manufacturer ensures that if there is an issue with the part, you have access to reliable customer service and troubleshooting.
      Improved Safety: OEM control modules are directly connected to critical safety features in your vehicle, such as airbags, antilock braking systems (ABS), and traction control. Ensuring these modules are in top working order is essential to maintaining the safety of the vehicle.
      The Role of OEM Control Modules in Modern Vehicles
      Modern vehicles rely on multiple control modules to ensure that everything from the engine to the infotainment system is functioning correctly. Some of the most common OEM control modules include:
      Engine Control Module (ECM): This module manages engine functions such as fuel injection, ignition timing, and emissions control, ensuring that the engine operates efficiently. Transmission Control Module (TCM): The TCM controls the vehicle’s transmission system, adjusting shifting patterns for smoother performance. Body Control Module (BCM): This module is responsible for non-powertrain functions, such as lighting, door locks, and interior comfort features. ABS Control Module: This module manages the anti-lock braking system, preventing wheel lockup during heavy braking and improving vehicle stability. These are just a few examples, but in today’s vehicles, the integration of electronics in the form of OEM control modules is essential for ensuring everything functions smoothly.
      Choosing the Right OEM Control Module
      When it comes to replacing or upgrading an OEM control module, it's essential to choose one that fits your specific vehicle model and requirements. Working with trusted auto parts suppliers, like Clifford Auto Parts, ensures that you get a quality OEM control module at a competitive price. It’s always a good idea to check with an expert to ensure you're selecting the right part to suit your vehicle’s needs.
      Conclusion
      OEM control modules are integral components of modern vehicles, offering superior performance, reliability, and compatibility. Whether you're replacing a faulty module or upgrading your vehicle, choosing OEM parts is the best way to ensure your car or truck continues to run at its best. With their long-lasting durability and guaranteed fit, OEM control modules are a wise investment in the future of your vehicle. Always choose quality and reliability by opting for OEM when upgrading or replacing essential control modules.
      By understanding the importance of OEM control modules, vehicle owners can make informed decisions that ensure their vehicle performs optimally for years to come.
    • Dorman Products
      Technician Challenge: Headlight Range Control #Dashlightquiz #TechnicianChallenge
      By Dorman Products
      Technician Challenge: Headlight Range Control #Dashlightquiz #TechnicianChallenge
    • Garage Gurus
      Garage Gurus | How to Do a Cylinder Leak Down Test
      By Garage Gurus
      Garage Gurus | How to Do a Cylinder Leak Down Test
    • Dorman Products
      Technician Challenge: Adaptive Cruise Control
      By Dorman Products
      Technician Challenge: Adaptive Cruise Control
    • Counterman
      Understanding the Emission-Control System
      By Counterman
      Once hated and touted as “power robbers,” we’ve learned over the years how emission-control systems not only protect our environment, but also how they contribute to the overall performance, economy and longevity of today’s engines as an integral part of the combustion process.
      Emission-control components are high on the list of parts you sell, because they affect vehicle operation, and if they’re not working properly, they result in the dreaded “Check Engine” light. There are many ways that the various emission systems on a vehicle tie together, but a look at the main players can help you develop a base understanding of how the overall system works.
      Positive Crankcase Ventilation
      Any internal-combustion engine produces blowby gasses, which are gasses from the combustion process that are forced past the piston rings into the crankcase. These gasses must be vented to prevent pressure buildup, which would cause oil to be forced past gaskets and seals. These gasses also combine with the oil vapors in the crankcase to form sludge and dilute the oil with unburned fuel.
      From the early days, we knew that blowby gasses had to go, so we got rid of them – right into the atmosphere. At least that’s what we did until the 1960s (hello smog).
      To reduce air pollution, auto manufacturers began to utilize positive-crankcase-ventilation (PCV) systems. PCV was a simple system to draw the vapors out of the crankcase using engine vacuum. The vapors and unburned fuel were then drawn back into the cylinders and burned, eliminating them as a source of air pollution.
      But there was another benefit to it. Normal system operation pulled fresh air through the crankcase, which removed moisture – extending oil life and reducing sludge. Since PCV is more or less a controlled vacuum leak, the flow rate is important, and even on older vehicles, the fuel systems are calibrated to work in conjunction with it.
      PCV systems still are utilized on modern engines, and engine-management systems are able to monitor their operation by checking the flow rate. The efficiency of modern PCV systems not only reduces emissions but also drastically extends oil life. PCV components range from the simple valves on an older vehicle to more complex integrated PCV orifices/oil separators found on or as part of the valve cover on many new engines.
      Other PCV-related components include crankcase-ventilation filters and breather hoses. Don’t forget that these components are designed and calibrated to each engine and fuel system, even on older vehicles. Just because it fits doesn’t mean it’s correct, and also beware of aftermarket “catch cans.” Many people think this is a performance upgrade that traps oil vapor and contaminants before they’re drawn into the intake. This is true on some older vehicles, but on most modern engines the PCV system is so refined that it cannot be improved upon. Installing a “catch can” on these engines will most likely only result in a drivability issue.
      Exhaust-Gas Recirculation
      Exhaust-gas recirculation (EGR) is an emission-control technique designed specifically to reduce the formation of nitrogen oxide (NOx), a very unhealthy and dangerous gas that’s formed during the high temperature and pressure of combustion. It works by recirculating exhaust gas back into the cylinders and cooling the combustion process.
      In reality, it doesn’t actually “cool” the combustion process, but by displacing oxygen, it prevents the air/fuel mixture from burning hot enough to form NOx. EGR can offer advantages to the combustion process, and modern engine-management systems are designed to maximize this, with the efficiency of gasoline engines often improved as a result. Not only is it illegal, but disabling any type of EGR control also will result in a loss of performance.
      On diesel engines, EGR is again an effective emission-control device, but becomes considerably more complicated. Since diesel fuel ignites with the heat of compression, higher temperatures promote efficiency … but unfortunately also the formation of NOx. To combat this, many modern diesel engines have EGR coolers that allow a larger mass of recirculated exhaust gas into the intake.
      But, this reduces the efficiency of the combustion process, which creates excessive soot. To combat this, a diesel-particulate filter (DPF) is installed in the exhaust to capture and store the soot, which must be burned off periodically to regenerate the filter.
      Since EGR systems are critical for emissions and performance, they’re closely monitored and controlled by the powertrain control module. Common EGR components include everything from the common EGR valve to pressure sensors, EGR tubes, EGR coolers, control solenoids and pressure sensors.
      Exhaust and Catalytic Converters
      Catalytic converters need no introduction. Since the 1970s, they’ve been the major emission component that chemically converts the harmful pollutants in the exhaust into harmless gasses. On todays’ vehicles, they work in conjunction with oxygen and/or air/fuel ratio sensors, also well-known emission-control components.
      Before the converters (pre-cat), the oxygen sensors report the air/fuel ratio to the engine control module so it can adjust the fuel mixture based on operating conditions and ensure that an improper mixture will not damage the converter itself. After the converter, a post-cat sensor again sends a signal to the engine control module, from which it determines the efficiency of the converter.
      The diesel side again can seem more complicated. They too have what appears as a catalytic converter, but on a diesel, they contain not only a catalyst but also the DPF. They’re sometimes referred to as aftertreatment devices, and overall design can differ between vehicle makes. The process that occurs is referred to as selective catalytic reduction (SCR), during which the catalyst works in conjunction with injected diesel-exhaust fluid (DEF) to convert NOx into nitrogen, carbon dioxide and water vapor.
      The DPF traps the soot, which is burned off through passive or active regeneration, and in some situations the process must be performed by a service technician. NOx sensors monitor the entire SCR process.
      In addition to catalytic converters, exhaust-related emission components include oxygen, air/fuel ratio and NOx sensors; DEF and DEF-related components; and diesel aftertreatment devices.
      Evaporative Emissions
      Evaporative emissions refer to anything that helps keep fuel vapors in the tank and out of the atmosphere. This requires very strict monitoring of the pressure in the tank, and when venting is required, filtering of the fumes. EVAP canisters – sometimes referred to as charcoal canisters – store fuel vapors to prevent them from reaching the atmosphere until they can be drawn in by the engine.
      The entire process of evaporative emissions requires multiple components, including the EVAP canister, hoses, lines, canister-purge solenoids, canister-purge valves, canister-vent solenoids and leak-detection pumps. The design of these systems often differs between manufacturer, so it can take some time to get used to all the different components.
      The post
      link hidden, please login to view appeared first on link hidden, please login to view.
      link hidden, please login to view

×
×
  • Create New...